This week I was fascinated as I read part of Bernard Poduska's book, "Till Debt Do Us Part". Some of the conflict in my marriage has stemmed from very different money management styles for me and my husband. The chapter I read was focused on rules that follow us into our marriages from our family of origin, and also the typical money management styles according to birth order. My husband is a first born, and I am a last born. I actually laughed out loud as I read the analysis of those birth orders, since my husband and I apparently switched management styles in some sort of Freaky Friday-esque personality swap.
According to research cited by Poduska, first borns place a high value on self control, and view impulse spending as a serious character flaw. They value sacrifice and planning before any purchase, and are often at odds with others over their miserly ways. Conversely, last borns supposedly lack any self control when it comes to money, and will buy whatever they want, whenever they want- regardless of the financial consequences.
The most fascinating thing about the information was that both my husband and I have many of the classic traits of our respective birth orders- he has a need to control and is very driven, while I am extremely easy going and value feelings over results. It's only in the financial realm that we completely depart from expected behaviors. I manage all of the bills and bank accounts and have major frustration over my husband's inability to budget and resist impulse purchases.
As I thought about financial behaviors in each of our family of origin vs. our birth order, I have to conclude that what happens in our family of origin has a more powerful impact than birth order. My husband was raised in a family that lived paycheck to paycheck and moved multiple times each year to find greener grass. They never had enough money to pay their bills, but would go to Disneyland or professional sporting events. On the other hand, my family was very financially secure, but both of my parents are extremely frugal and we never spent money frivolously. Shopping around for the best price and only buying what was needed were ingrained in our minds. In both of our families, both parents seemed to follow the same money philosophy.
Since we have never been able to mesh our money management styles, I wonder what traits our children will take away from our family?